Published on February 10th, 2015 | by Kate Ellis


“Independent shops are not above criticism”

Reading is very protective of its independent businesses. Looking at the dearth of small and local shops in the town centre this might not appear to be the case – but we will fiercely defend the few independents we have. As a town overwhelmed with chains and clone stores we are keen to protect and celebrate our independent shops – however, to nurture local businesses in Reading we must also be brave enough to criticise them.

Two recent experiences brought me to this conclusion. The first was when I had a few friends come visit me in Reading last weekend. We decided to go out for lunch and I was very keen to show off the more interesting and trendy parts of Reading, so I took them to one of my favourite coffee shops in town, Workhouse Coffee.

However, to my surprise, neither of my friends particularly liked Workhouse and were more interested in visiting some of the chain restaurants along the Oracle riverside. I was quick to defend the café which I’ve always felt is the closest Reading has to its own Central Perk: a trendy, independent coffee shop which is a great place to chat away with friends for a couple of hours. However, I realised that my defense of Workhouse was not based on its products or service, but on the fact that it is the only coffee shop of its kind in Reading.

The second experience was a recent review by Edible Reading in which they rightly argued that people in Reading shouldn’t settle for ‘good enough’ and should instead be encouraged to criticise disappointing events and businesses. Edible Reading’s example was the recent ‘Winter Wonderland’ in Forbury Gardens which ended up being little more than a tacky funfair. Not a bad thing by any means, but it could have been something so much better.

My friends who visited recently come from a town with an abundance of independent and local businesses. For them, Reading was fun to visit because they could go to Jamie’s Italian, Apple or Wagamama’s – chains they didn’t have in their home town. Independent businesses held no special value to them and could be judged on an equal level to chains.

To people in Reading, ‘independent business’ often conjures up images of trendy bars, boutique cinemas and quirky coffee shops. But ‘independent’ can also mean nail bars, mobile phone repair shops and greasy spoons. Because we have so few independents we treat them with reverence that isn’t entirely deserved, as an independent shop can be just as lifeless and soulless as a chain store. Alt Reading, for example, exists to champion independent businesses but mostly focuses on the trendier and more interesting places opening.

As a town we are scared to criticise local businesses because we fear we might scare them away. That if we encourage people to be critical of our cafes and bars we might lose the few independent businesses we have. But if we ever expect our local sector to improve then we need to be brave enough to criticise restaurants whose service is poor, pubs who actually don’t offer anything unique and shops which aren’t that special. How can we claim to support good local businesses if we’re unwilling to recognise those which are bad?

We should definitely be encouraging and supporting independents that want to open up in Reading: a good independent shop is able to provide a service and experience that you will not be able to find anywhere else. But we mustn’t hold independents to a lower standard than chain shops. As Edible Reading said, we must not settle for ‘good enough’ and instead champion those shops, restaurants, bars, pubs and cafes that truly are special.

Do you have an opinion you want to share about a Reading topic or issue. Get in touch!

Tags: , , , ,

About the Author

is a English Literature student at the University of Reading. She is interested in vintage clothes and oddities.

  • SweetTooth

    Just yesterday I had a bad experience in a chain cafe that is marketing itself as a ‘posh’ place. The service, atmosphere and even the food was quite bad. My friend had invited me for a birthday treat and I felt sorry that she had to pay a lot of money for a very poor deal. I wished we had gone to a little independent one I have been to before, where, yes, the choice would have been a lot more limited but the service and atmosphere would have been much better.

    With regards to the Christmas markets in Reading: How does a sausage stall and a mulled wine stall make for a “Wundermarkt” (miracle market). And does using a German word make it any more attractive or authentic? It seems that Reading feels the need to ‘have’ what other places have whether it is suitable or not. Why not admit that it does not have the space and atmosphere to create a truly wonderful market but aim to deliver something within its means and ability. It took all of 5 minutes to ‘do’ the town hall square market; it was quite pathetic. The indoor market at the 3B Cafe was the best event but only lasted a few days which was probably enough for something of that size. The announcements that precede this kind of events give the public the impression of something big and magical and wonderful happening and when you arrive, it is small and disappointing.

  • kdf9012

    All my friends love going to Sweeny’s Pie shop when they visit Reading – well kept ales, nice pies and decent prices – but then, not every town has a pie shop.

Back to Top ↑